This was published 7 years ago

Health Minister Brad Hazzard wants jail time for fake doctors

An accused fake doctor who operated in public hospitals for more than a decade without being detected was eventually discovered by a private medical company.

Shyam Acharya, who is believed to have left the country, is accused of working under false pretences at hospitals in Manly, Wyong, Hornsby and Gosford from 2003 to 2014.

NSW Health Minster Brad Hazzard has called for a law change that would allow fake doctors to be jailed.

Mr Acharya is alleged to have stolen the name and medical qualifications of Indian doctor Sarang Chitale to become registered as a medical practitioner in NSW, where he worked in hospital emergency departments until he failed to meet Australian Health Practitioner Registration Agency requirements.

Mr Acharya is believed to have stolen the identity of Indian doctor Sarang Chitale.

Neither the Health Care Complaints Commission nor the Medical Council of NSW received any complaints about him during his 11 years of practice.

After leaving hospitals, Mr Acharya worked for private medical research company Novotech under the same fake identity between June 2015 and September 2016, when management discovered he may have misrepresented his identity and qualifications.

"Novotech immediately took steps to investigate and contacted the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency and the NSW police (amongst others)," Novotech general counsel Veronica Holloway said in a statement.

"Those organisations conducted their own investigations into this issue, with which Novotech fully co-operated."

A coroner has called for NSW Health Minister Brad Hazzard to consider holding a meeting to develop best practices around emergency room violence. Dominic Lorrimer

But it was two months before AHPRA notified NSW Health, which commenced its own investigation upon receiving the information in November.

AHPRA has laid charges against Mr Acharya of using the title of health practitioner when not registered and he faces a maximum fine of $30,000.

The agency declined to comment while the case was before the courts, but it is unclear whether Mr Acharya will face a penalty because his whereabouts are unknown.

Mr Hazzard said the $30,000 fine for people who falsely presented themselves as medical practitioners was "woefully inadequate".

He will also raise it with other health ministers at the next Council of Australian Governments meeting later this month.

"I'm horrified that this fellow managed to get into the NSW hospital system," Mr Hazzard said.

"If we can catch this guy he deserves jail and the problem is at the moment that the maximum you can get is $30,000. Greg Hunt and I – and, I would believe the other ministers – are intent on changing this."

Mr Hazzard said doctor registration was tightened in 2011 with the establishment of AHPRA, which gave Mr Acharya limited registration in 2012 and 2013.

"But by the third registration his luck ran out," Mr Hazzard said.

Opposition health spokesman Walt Secord said the case demonstrated a systemic failure at all levels of government.

NSW Health said in a statement that its recruitment processes had improved since 2011, with personal referees now sought for all overseas doctors.

An international firm based in the US runs checks on original documents.

Federal Health Minister Mr Hunt said he would work with the states to ensure there were heavy penalties for people who falsely claimed to be doctors, including the option of a jail term.

"Impersonating medical professionals is a serious crime and should be treated as such," Mr Hunt said.

Novotech said Mr Acharya did not have any contact or responsibility for patients while he was working at the company.

NSW Health is reviewing its patient records and has advised anybody with concerns to call the Central Coast Local Health District in 4320 3920 or the Northern Sydney Local Health District on 9462 9778.

Most Viewed in National