Japan’s Kyoto to ban visitors from geisha district area after surge in ‘out-of-control’ incidents

Such incidents in Gion include tourists pulling kimonos worn by the geisha and forcing the traditional entertainers to pose for photos
Japan has seen a surge in foreign visitors in recent months, including in Kyoto, where the city’s geisha are a major tourist attraction

Japan

Julian Ryall

Published: 12:00pm, 6 Mar 2024

Why you can trust SCMP

The local council in Kyoto’s historic Gion will ban sightseers from the district’s narrow backstreets where the Japanese city’s iconic geisha trot daintily between client engagements after a spike in cases of the traditional entertainers being accosted by “out-of-control” tourists.

Starting in April, the council will cordon off the maze of alleyways in Gion, which are lined by restaurants and tea houses where the geisha work. Entry will be limited to the geisha, their clients and residents.

It is the latest move to protect the entertainers after the local council and city government imposed restrictions on tourists coming into the area about a decade ago when visitor numbers soared and the “geisha paparazzi” started to make life difficult for the women.

There are numerous tales of geisha having their way blocked by groups of tourists as they took photos, of the women having their kimonos tugged and the delicate ornaments in their hair touched. Others have reported tourists demanding that the geisha pose for photos and stopping them from going into tea houses for their client appointments.

In 2019, the local authorities started putting up signs in multiple languages stating that taking photos of the geisha was prohibited and that a fine of 10,000 yen (US$66) would be imposed for non-compliance. The fine, however, is impossible to enforce.

Kyoto’s locals say city has too many tourists. New mayor vows to fight that

Gion was relatively quiet during the pandemic. But the number of foreign arrivals in Japan has rebounded in the last six months, and it is on course this year to surpass a record 31.88 million in 2019. Millions of travellers have visited Kyoto in recent years, many of whom would try to get a glimpse of the geisha in the ancient capital.

The ban will not cover the main road that runs through the district Hanamikoji because it is a public thoroughfare. This has led to concerns that the new access rules might cause an overcrowding of tourists in the area.

“Mainland Chinese tourists are not back in Kyoto yet, but because of the weak yen it is suddenly very cheap to come to Japan, and sometimes it’s like you’re in Thailand with all the tourists,” said Peter Macintosh, a Canadian author who has lived in Kyoto since 1993 and organises geisha events.

“They put up signs a few years ago saying photographing the geisha was banned, but it has no legal standing and everyone just ignores it,” he said.

His friends and contacts in the geisha scene fear a resurgence of shocking incidents in Gion even as their number has fallen. Geisha have told Macintosh of tourists flicking cigarette ash down the exposed back of their white-painted necks and stealing their hair ornaments.

Japan has paid millions over American military aircraft noise. Why not the US?

In one incident, a foreign tourist threw US$10,000 and his room key at a geisha who ignored him, Macintosh said.

Tourists are not just interfering with the geisha. Many of them touch the lanterns that hang outside restaurants and tea houses and enter private property to take photos, Macintosh said. A particular source of irritation is the visitors who rent kimonos for the day and stand in the middle of streets to take selfies, he added.

Macintosh said he has seen kimono-clad foreign tourists lying on the road to take photos.

“It’s crazy behaviour,” he said. “It’s completely out of control.”

Macintosh called for a tourist police unit to be set up with the power to levy fines against visitors for disruptive behaviour, which he believed would “very quickly scare people into behaving better”.

01:30

Kyoto to ban tourists from accessing famous geisha district after surge in harassment cases

The city’s tourism officials, however, are not considering such a step.

“Before the pandemic, there were some nuisance incidents involving visitors, such as unauthorised photo-taking, pulling the geisha’s kimonos and entering private property,” a city official, who declined to be identified, told This Week in Asia. “It is not as bad as before the pandemic, but there are still [such] incidents from time to time.”

Kyoto has been producing and delivering leaflets, posters and other messages to raise awareness about the standards of behaviour that are expected of foreign tourists, the official added.

Police in Gion have also offered help to geisha, such as teaching them self-defence after some of the entertainers expressed concern about walking between entertainment venues by themselves at night.