METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR TESTING COMMUTATORS
Technical Field
This invention relates to methods and apparatus for testing, qualifying and/or evaluating the performance capabilities and/or characteristics of commutators.
Background Commutator and motor designers are regularly faced with a number of difficult questions, including:
• Can the commutator handle the design speed?
• Can the commutator handle the anticipated surface temperature?
• The motor load is oscillating. Temperature and speed are changing non-linearly. How will the commutator perform in this "thermal- dynamic chaos"?
• Did the motor designer make the right decision for a brush- commutator cooling system?
• Did the commutator manufacturer over design the commutator for this application, and create unnecessary cost for the manufacturer and customer?
• Will a sample commutator fail a customer life-test, thereby losing potential sales and damaging the manufacturer's reputation?
• A major designer wants to add more power to a motor using the same commutator. Can the commutator manufacturer make the right recommendation?
There are many mathematical models and test methods to address one or more of these questions. However, there are no current tests which will allow a
commutator or motor manufacturer to determine the suitability of various commutators for particular applications rapidly and accurately.
Summary of the Invention
This invention provides methods and apparatus for testing, qualifying and/or evaluating the performance capabilities and/or characteristics of commutators wherein a commutator is preheated to a first predetermined temperature, held at a substantially constant temperature, and rotated at increasing speeds until the commutator fails.
Preferably, additional and substantially comparable commutators are preheated to the same predetermined temperature and rotated at increasing speeds until they fail. The data from these tests establish a predictable range of speeds at which this commutator can be expected to operate satisfactorily at this temperature. Additional commutators are preheated to higher temperatures and rotated at increasing speeds, while held at these temperatures, until they fail. Speed/temperature failure data from these tests provide a graph that enables designers = to determine appropriate speed and temperature ranges for commutators over a wide range of applications. The tests can be performed rapidly and economically, and are suitable for almost any type of commutator design. Thus, this invention enables commutator and motor designers to design, select and modify commutators for a wide range of motor designs.
Other features and advantages of this invention will be apparent from the following detailed description.
Drawings Figure 1 is a schematic representation of one form of apparatus embodying this invention.
Figure 2 is an enlarged cross-sectional view of a support for commutators in the apparatus of Figure 1.
Figure 3 is a typical graph of the results produced by the methods and apparatus of this invention. Detailed Description
Figure 1 illustrates one test system embodying this invention. Tests are performed in a chamber, generally referred to as 10, with a cylindrical lower section 11 and a upper section 13 in the form of a truncated cone with a open top 15. Lower section 11 is lined with lead or another impact absorbing material 21 to prevent damage from fragments of bursting commutators, and contains a central, tubular opening 17 with a glass plate 19 mounted therein, through which commutator failures can be observed and recorded.
A variable speed motor 25, capable of speeds up to about 100,000 rpm, is mounted above or slightly inside the open top 15 of container 10. The speed of the motion is governed by a motor controller 59. A flexible support wire or rod 29 depends from a chuck 27 on the lower end of motor 25. The commutator C to be tested is supported on the lower portion of wire 29 by a support, generally referred to as 30, which is illustrated in Figure 2. Several supports are provided so that commutators of different sizes can be tested. Each support has a central shaft 31 that extends through the commutator C to be tested. Preferably, to help ensure smooth operation, the outer diameter of shaft 31 is .0005" to .0010" smaller than the central bore of the commutator. The commutator is held on shaft 31 by a shoulder 33 on the upper portion of the shaft, and an adjusting nut 35 that is threaded onto the lower end
of the shaft. The support wire or rod 29 extends into shaft 31, and the shaft is secured to the support wire or rod 29 with a set screw 37.
Support wire 29 must be stiff enough to prevent excessive movement of commutator C as the commutator is accelerated by motor 31 , but flexible enough to allow the commutator to balance itself, and to protect the shaft and bearings of motor 25 by absorbing vibrations when a commutator bursts. When a commutator rotates, it will balance itself by orbiting in a small circle about the central axis of support wire 29. To accommodate this motion, the commutator under test is preferably surrounded by a sensing wire 41 positioned about 0.25 inche from the commutator, when mounted in support 30 but at rest. This allows the commutator to move far enough from the central axis to balance the system, while the commutator remains intact, but positions the sensing wire 41 to reliably detect commutator failures.
When commutators fail in a centrifugal, thermo dynamic test such as this, failure usually occurs in a "burst" or loss of one or more parts of the commutator. The commutating elements, i.e., the bars which are spaced around the periphery of cylindrical commutators such as the one illustrated in Figure 2, or the pie-shaped segments that are attached to one end of face commutators, are the parts that are most likely to fail. Sensing wire 41 is placed so that flying pieces will strike the wire 41 when they are thrown from the commutator as the commutator fails. A movement sensor 43, such as a proximity sensor, laser sensor, magnet or electrical contact detects movement of sensing wire 41 and triggers a controller 45 for a high speed camera 47, positioned beneath glass plate 19, which records the failure of the commutator.
The temperature of commutator C is controlled during a test by one or more heaters 51 mounted near the top of the upper section 13 of test chamber 10. The temperature is monitored by one or more temperature gauges 53, also mounted near the top of the upper section of the test chamber. The temperature gauge(s) are preferably infrared gauges such as the Model No. SXSMTCF2L2 from Kirk Company of Berea, Ohio. These gauges can provide an indication of the commutator temperature which is accurate to within 6°F.
Signals from the temperature gauge(s) 53 are supplied to a temperature controller 55 and to a temperature-speed interface controller 57. Temperature controller 53 controls heater(s) 51. With heaters 51 and infrared temperature gauges, temperature controller 55 can reliably maintain the temperature of the commutator C under test within 6°F degrees of the desired level. When the temperatures reach a preset level, temperature-speed interface controllers 57 signals motor controller 59 to accelerate the rotation of the commutator C at a controlled rate, normally between about 100 and about 200 RPM/sec.
A test or qualification of a particular commutator is initiated by supporting one of these commutators upon wire 29, as illustrated in Figure 2, and preheating the commutator to a predetermined temperature, such as 100°F. Preferably the commutator is rotated slowly, e.g., at about 100 to 200 RPM, to ensure even heating. When the commutator has reached the desired temperature, as determined by temperature gauge 53, motor controller 59 gradually and steadily increases the speed of motor 31, typically at a rate of about 100 to 200 RPM per sec, and, until the commutator bursts or otherwise fails structurally in a manner that dislodges commutator bars, face segments or other pieces that move sensing wire 41. This is
detected by sensor 43, and the strobe and camera controller 45 cause camera 47, with the assistance of strobe lights 49, to take a series of pictures of the failing commutator. With the illustrated system the first picture can be taken within 10 milliseconds following the first contact with sensing wire 41. Modern high speed cameras can take additional pictures at a rate of 8,000 frames per second or more. In addition to providing data for the qualification of the commutator, this system provides valuable information that can be used to improve the design and prevent future failures.
The test as described above is then repeated with several identical or substantially equivalent commutators to provide a set of data points for the failure speed for this commutator at this temperature. Typically 3 to 5 commutators may be tested at each temperature, and the failure speeds for the individual tests are averaged or otherwise adjusted to provide a composite speed/temperature data point.
Additional tests are conducted at a series of higher temperatures, such as 200°F, 300°F, 400°F, 500°F and 600°F, with similar numbers of commutators being tested at each temperature. The composite failure speed/temperature data points provide curves which can be used to rapidly and accurately predict the performance capabilities of the commutator under a wide range of speed and temperature conditions. Two such TDCC™ curves are illustrated in Figure 3. These curves can be prepared for virtually any common commutator, and provide both motor manufacturers and commutator suppliers with a number of significant advantages. Motor manufacturers obtain:
• Heat transfer parameters and calculations;
• Standardized designs;
• Tool savings through use of existing commutator characteristics in motor design; and
• Substantial cost savings by avoiding over-engineering. The commutator supplier obtains:
• Easy, economical and accurate commutator evaluations;
• A valuable tool for evaluating molding compounds, anchoring systems and other aspects of commutator design and engineering;
• A strong base point for future development;
• Product standardization; and
• A superior technical program for commutator marketing and sales.
Those skilled in the art of commutator design and application will readily appreciate other advantages they can obtain through the use of the equipment and techniques described above. They will also appreciate that the specific systems and methods described herein are merely illustrative. Many modifications can be made these systems and methods within the scope of this invention, which is defined by the following claims: