VISIBILITY SENSOR SYSTEM
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The present invention relates generally to a sensor system to detect visibility and,
more specifically, to a visibility sensor system having a removable sensor head that may be
removed for servicing.
Reduced visibility on highways due to fog or blowing dust has often been the
cause of tragic traffic accidents. Fog, especially in mountainous regions, has a tendency to build
up in patchy dense pockets. At highway speeds, in particular, a driver may suddenly find himself
within one of these patchy dense fog pockets.
The ability to adequately warn drivers of dense fog is highly desirable. If
adequate warning is provided to drivers, drivers may then reduce their speed based on the density
of the fog. Adequate warnings will reduce loss of life.
Several optical and non-optical methods for determining the presence of fog are
known. Most, however, are not suitable for highway visibility sensors. There are several optical
systems that may be used. Radar and lidar systems are used to gather general weather data. Such
systems are too expensive, bulky, insensitive and difficult to use on a highway. Closed circuit
television has limited use for visibility detection, but it cannot function at night and requires
monitoring by an operator. Airports commonly use transmissometers. Transmissometers
measure the transmission of a light beam traveling a given path. Transmissometers are very
expensive and require considerable maintenance and thus are not suitable to detect patchy
highway fog. Coulter counters are often used in clean room monitoring. Coulter counters are
very expensive and have high maintenance and power consumption requirements.
Non-optical devices such as triboelectric current sensors depend on the flow of
gas rubbing against an electrode. Fog, however, frequently occurs in quiet atmospheric
conditions. Spark discharge sensors require sensor electrodes to continually be kept clean and
thus maintenance costs are prohibitive. A dosimeter-type particle density measurement device
does not provide real-time data.
Another optical device for measuring fog is a nephelometer. Known
nephelometers have expensive optical systems and are very large in size. The optical system
requires constant maintenance to clean the windows through which the optics are directed.
In particular, there are problems applying a nephelometer for activating a fog lamp
in a vehicle. Such nephelometers generally include a "window" through which light is
transmitted and received. "Window" contamination in a nephelometer (i) makes accurate
measurement of fog almost impossible; (ii) requires costly maintenance (constant cleaning);
(iii) wipers to clean the "window" are not a solution; (iv) makes it difficult to calibrate even with
an additional optical system; and (v) contributes to crosstalk through the "window" material. An
example of such a prior art device is disclosed in U.S. 5,349,267.
Another problem with nephelometers involves detector saturation due to "wrong"
look direction. Yet another problem with a nephelometers involves airflow "turbulence" which
causes measurement errors. Other methods for fog detection include: coulter counter, spark
discharge, transmissometer, radar, lidar, CCTV, etc. These approaches, however, are expensive
and/or hard to install.
In certain situations, it may be desirable for the vehicle to have a visibility
detection system associated therewith. It would likely be cost prohibitive to provide highway
visibility detection systems across the country. Therefore, it is desirable to provide a visibility
sensor system associated with the vehicle.
On ships, it is difficult to determine visibility due to lack of background for
comparison. For ships, it may also be desirable to locate a visibility sensor on the ship.
It would therefore be desirable to provide a visibility sensor system that
overcomes the drawbacks of the prior art. Particularly, it would be desirable to provide a
visibility sensor system that is inexpensive, has low maintenance, and is reliable to endure the
conditions experienced on a highway.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
It is therefore an object of the invention to provide an improved visibility
detection system. More specifically, it is an object of the invention to provide a visibility
detection system suitable for incorporation on an automotive vehicle.
According to one embodiment of the invention, a detector includes a housing
having a first hollow opening and a second hollow opening. A first light source is fixed within
the housing and directs light through the first hollow opening to a sample volume outside the
housing. A first light detector receives light reflected from the sample volume through the
second hollow opening. A controller is coupled to the first light source and the first detector.
The controller determines an output indicative of visibility from the light received by the first
light detector.
In another embodiment of the visibility sensor system, a display may be coupled
to the controller to warn drivers of the existence of fog ahead. The display may also indicate a
safe driving speed through the fog.
In yet another embodiment of the invention, a means for compensating for the
deterioration of the first detector may be included. To compensate for the deterioration of the
first detector, a second light source may be placed adjacent to the first detector and illuminate
the first detector with a predetermined amount of light. The controller then calculates the
deterioration of the first detector in its visibility calculation. In another aspect of the invention,
a means for determining deterioration of the first light source may be concluded. The means for
compensating for deterioration of the first light source includes a second detector located
adjacent to the first light source. The second detector would provide feedback to the controller
as to the deterioration of the light source. The controller would then compensate for any
deterioration of the first light source in its calculation for visibility.
In yet another embodiment of the invention, a method for detecting visibility
comprises the steps of illuminating a sample volume of air from a first hollow opening within
a housing using a first light source, detecting the amount of light scattering from the volume of
air with a first detector that receives light through a second hollow opening and calculating a
visibility factor based upon the light scattering from the fog particles in the volume of air.
In one aspect of the method for calculating visibility, the calculation may take into
consideration deterioration of the first detector and the first light source.
In still another embodiment of the invention, a removable sensor head comprises
a sensor enclosure defining a first optical port and a second optical port. A first circuit board is
coupled to the sensor enclosure. A first connector is coupled to the first circuit board. A light
source is coupled to the first circuit board, which positions the light source within the first optical
port. A second circuit board is coupled to the sensor enclosure. A second connector coupled to
the second circuit board. A light detector is coupled to the second circuit board. The second
circuit board positions the light detector within the second optical port. A calibration memory
is coupled to the second circuit board.
In a further embodiment of the invention, a visibility sensor assembly has a
housing having a sensor head opening. A removable sensor head assembly is removably coupled
to the housing within the sensor head opening. The sensor head assembly has a sensor enclosure
and a connector. An electronics module is coupled to the sensor head through the connector.
In yet another embodiment, a rain sensor is provided, which is configured to close
one or more shutters that cover the first and second openings. This has the advantage of
minimizing the entry of contaminants.
In yet another embodiment, a sensor enclosure is provided which is configured
to produce an airflow therethrough such that contaminants are swept through the enclosure. This
has the advantage of minimizing the contamination of the light source and/or light detector.
One advantage to providing a removable sensor head is that the maintenance costs
are reduced because the sensor head may be easily replaced.
One advantage of the present invention is that it features a no window/no lens
approach. That is, no optics or windows are required within the hollow openings through which
light is transmitted and received. This eliminates a major problem for optical sensor systems.
That is, eliminating the persistent need for cleaning of the optics or windows, wherein such
maintenance frequency may be reduced to less than V,0 that of existing nephelometers.
Another advantage of a fog sensor according to the invention involves
synchronous detection for ambient light rejection.
Another advantage of the present invention is that short periodic onsite
inspections for calibration are not required. The sensor system provides a means for
compensating for the deterioration of a detector and light source. The sensor system also can
provide a self check and report the results to a central monitoring station.
Another advantage of the present invention is that a variety of communication
options may be supported. For example, communication to a centrally located communication
center may be provided via fiber optics, a cable, RF, telephone, and cellular phones.
Yet another advantage of the present invention is that the system operates using
a significantly less amount of energy compared to that of other known fog detection systems.
The sample rate for determining fog may be changed depending on whether the conditions
around the sensor are changing to make fog more likely. If the conditions are such that fog is
likely, the sample rate may be increased. Power use is thereby minimized.
Yet another advantage of the present invention is the compactness of the sensor
system. A separate post does not need to be installed along the highway for a sensor system.
The sensor system may be installed on currently existing posts such as speed limit signs or other
highway signs. If used for a vehicle application, the package size and weight are small.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
Other features and advantages of the present invention will become apparent from
the following detailed description which should be read in conjunction with the drawings in
which:
Figure 1 is a diagrammatic view of a highway warning system employing a
visibility sensor according to the present invention;
Figure 2 is a diagrammatic of a visibility sensor head according to the present
invention;
Figure 3 is a diagrammatic view of an alternative embodiment of a visibility
sensor;
Figure 4 is a flow chart a method for operating a visibility sensor system to
conserve energy;
Figure 5 is a partial cutaway elevational view of a removable sensor head
according to the invention;
Figure 6 is a bottom view of the removable sensor head of Figure 5;
Figure 7 is a side elevational view of a removable sensor and electronic module
mounted within a housing;
Figure 8 is a bottom view of the visibility sensor system of Figure 7;
Figure 9 is a forward looking elevational view of an external rear view mirror
housing of a car having a visibility detection system located therein;
Figure 10 is a top elevational view of the rear view mirror housing with visibility
detection system of Figure 9;
Figure 11 is a side view of an automotive vehicle having a visibility detection
system mounted thereto;
Figure 12 is a side view of an automotive vehicle having a visibility detection
system mounted in an alternative manner to that of Figure 11;
Figure 13 is a cross-sectional view of an alternative sensor head housing;
Figure 14 is a side cross-sectional view similar to that of Figure 13 having sensor
located in a different orientation;
Figure 15 is a timing diagram view illustrating a synchronous detection feature
to identify precipitation according to the invention;
Figure 16 is a simplified, perspective view of a vehicle having a visibility
sensor/fog lamp combination embodiment according to the invention;
Figure 17 is a simplified front view of a preferred visibility sensor/fog lamp
combination embodiment according to the present invention;
Figure 18 is a side view, partially in section, of the embodiment shown in Figure
17;
Figure 19 is a simplified front view of an alternate, preferred visibility sensor/fog
lamp combination embodiment in accordance with the present invention;
Figure 20 is a simplified side view, partially in section, of the embodiment shown
in Figure 19;
Figure 21 is a simplified bottom view of yet another preferred visibility sensor/fog
lamp combination embodiment in accordance with the present invention;
Figure 22 is a simplified side view, partially in section, of the embodiment shown
in Figure 21;
Figure 23 is a simplified front view of still yet another preferred, visibility sensor/fog lamp combination embodiment in accordance with the present invention;
Figure 24 is a simplified side view, partially in section, of the embodiment
illustrated in Figure 23;
Figures 25-26 are bottom and side views, respectively, of still yet another
visibility sensor/fog lamp embodiment according to the present invention;
Figure 27 is a simplified side view of a visibility sensor/fog lamp as installed in
a front bumper; and
Figure 28 is an enlarged, partial side view showing a removable sensor enclosure
feature of one embodiment.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT
Referring now to the drawings, like reference numerals are used to identify
identical components in the various views. Although the invention will be illustrated in terms
of a fog detection visibility sensor, it will be appreciated that this invention may be used with
other visibility applications such as detection of blowing dust. In addition the visibility sensor
may be used for remote weather stations, airports and in maritime applications such as near a
lighthouse.
Referring now to Figure 1, a highway visibility detection system 10 has a
visibility sensor unit 12, a warning display 14 and a central controller 16. Visibility sensor unit
12 is preferably placed at eye level of a vehicle operator 18 in an automotive vehicle 20.
Visibility sensor unit 12, warning display 14 and central controller 16 may all be linked through
a communications network. A communication network, for example, may be cellular phone, RF,
cable, or optical fiber. As shown, each of visibility sensor unit 12, warning display 14 and
central controller 16 has an antenna 22 which may be used for RF or cellular communication
between each.
Upon detection of reduced visibility by visibility sensor unit 12, an indication as
to the distance of visibility may be displayed on warning display 14. Also, a suggested vehicle
speed may also be displayed on warning display 14.
Central controller 16 may be part of an intelligent transportation system (ITS).
The central controller 16 may be a manned controller which may perform a number of functions
such as initiating self-tests for the sensor unit 12 or sending a maintenance crew to service the
sensor in the event of contamination.
Referring now to Figure 2, visibility sensor unit 12 preferably has most of its
components sealed within a housing 24. Several visibility sensor units may be coupled within
one housing 24. The operation of the system is generally controlled by a micro controller 26.
A sensor head 28 is coupled to and controlled by micro controller 26. Sensor head 28 transmits
light to a sample volume 30 and provides micro controller 26 an indication of the amount of light
reflected from fog particles in a sample volume 30 below sensor head 28. A memory 32 is used
to store various information and is coupled to micro controller 26. Memory 32 is preferably
nonvolatile memory. Memory 32, for example, may contain a conversion factor for converting
the amount of light received by sensor head 28 to a visibility distance. Memory 32 may also
store service and calibration data, security codes, the serial number of the system, and visibility
data history.
10
Various sensors for sensing the atmospheric conditions around the housing 24 of
visibility sensor system 12 are coupled to micro controller 26. Such sensors may include an
atmosphere pressure sensor 34, one or more precipitation sensors 35, a temperature sensor 36 and
a humidity sensor 38.
Micro controller 26 may also be coupled to a communications link 40 that allows
micro controller 26 to communicate with a central controller 16. Although atmospheric pressure
sensor 34 has been shown coupled directly to micro controller 26, atmospheric pressure sensor
34 may be coupled directly to central controller 16. In such a case, atmospheric pressure data
would be provided through communications link 40 to micro controller 26. Micro controller 26
may be used to calculate the safe speed based upon the visibility detected by the sensor head 28.
The calculation of a safe speed may be done at a central controller.
Communications link 40 may be one of a number of types of communications
links that may be used to link micro controller 26 to central controller 16. Because the detector
system may be used in a variety of locations and conditions, flexibility for various types of
communications is required. Communications link 40 may, for example, be cellular telephone
link, an RF link, a fixed cable link, or optical fiber link. Communications link 40 may be used
to couple to a warning display (shown as 14 of Figure 1) on the highway.
Sensor head 28 has a first optical port 42 and a second optical port 44. First
optical port 42 has a first optical axis 46 and second optical port 44 has a second optical axis 48.
First optical axis 46 coincides with the longitudinal axis of first optical port 42. Likewise, the
second optical axis 48 coincides with the longitudinal axis of second optical port 44. An angle
50 between first optical axis 46 and second optical axis 48 may be about 150°.
11
In some applications the first optical port could coincide with the second optical
port. In such a case, no the ports would share the same longitudinal axis.
Recessed within first optical port 42 is a first light source 52. First light source
52 is preferably mounted in an end of first optical port 42. First light source 52 is preferably an
infrared light emitting diode having a relatively narrow beam width. First light source 52 may,
for example, have a total beam width of 10°. Light from first light source 52 emerges from first
optical port 42 at a first hollow opening 54. The cone of diverging light from first light source
52 illuminates a sample volume 30 outside first optical port 42.
Second optical port 44 has a first detector 56 located in an end thereof. First
detector 56 is sensitive to the wave length of light scattered from the sample volume 30. First
detector 56 may have a small surface area such as a five square millimeter surface area. Light
is reflected from particles in sample volume 30 into a second hollow opening 58. A light filter
60 may be interposed in the optical path between sample volume 30 and first detector 56. Filter
60 is provided to filter ambient light from first detector 56. First detector 56 provides an output
to micro controller 26 through a low noise amplifier 62 corresponding to the amount of light
reflected from particles in sample volume 30.
In one constructed embodiment, both second optical port 44 and first optical port
42 were constructed of .5 inch diameter by 3.5 inch tube.
A test light source 64 may be provided in second optical port 44. Test light source
64 is also preferably an infrared LED. Test light source 64 preferably has a relatively wide beam
width of approximately 80 ° so that light may be directed into second optical port 44 to first
detector 56. Test light source 64 is coupled to micro controller 26. Micro controller 26 controls
12
the operation of test light source 64. Test light source 64 is used during self testing and self
calibration as will be further described below.
A compensation detector 66 is coupled within first optical port 42. Compensation
detector 66 may have a smaller area such as a 1.5 square millimeter detection area.
Compensation detector 66 is coupled to micro controller 26 through a low noise amplifier 68,
compensation detector 66 provides feedback to micro controller 26 as to the operation of first
light source 52 during self test and self calibration.
A heater 70 is coupled adjacent to first light source 52 and first detector 56 to
prevent condensation on the optical surfaces. Heater 70 may be a tungsten wire or thermoplastic
element. Heater 70 may, for example, maintain a differential temperature of roughly 5° C
between the optical surfaces and ambient temperature to prevent condensation. A thermistor 72
may be coupled adjacent to the heater 70 to provide feedback to micro controller 26 so that the
functioning of heater 70 may be monitored.
An insect repellant 74 may be placed inside or adjacent to first optical port 42 and
second optical port 44. Insect repellant 74 may be a variety of insect repellant means. Insect
repellant may, for example, be a chemical known to be poisonous or repellant to the insects of
the area into which the highway visibility detector system will be placed.
A power source 76 is used to power the highway visibility detection system 10.
Highway visibility detection system 10 is flexible in the sense that it may operate from a variety
of sources of power. Power source 76 may, for example, be a solar cell coupled to storage
batteries. The power source may also be batteries or be coupled directly to a fixed power line.
Precipitation sensor 35 may comprise a conventional rain sensor or a conventional
snow sensor. Such sensors are known, for example, as described in K. Mori, et al. "An
13
Intermittent Wiper System with a Raindrop Sensor," SAE Technical Paper Series, SAE,
September 23-26, 1985, hereby incorporated by reference.
Referring now to Figure 3, an alternative embodiment for first optical port 42 and
second optical port 44 is shown. In this embodiment, first optical axis 46 and second optical axis
48 are not aligned with the longitudinal axis of first optical port 42 and second optical port 44.
First optical axis 46 and second optical axis 48 also preferably have an angle of about 150°
between them. The embodiment of Figure 3 operates in the same manner as that of Figure 2.
One method for operating a highway visibility detector system of the present
invention would be to continuously operate the system so as to constantly provide feedback to
the central control and to a warning display or several displays. Operating a fog detection system
continuously, however, is unnecessary and consumes power unnecessarily.
Referring now to Figure 4, based upon atmospheric conditions, the potential for
fog can be predicted. From meteorology, a saturation surface, which is sometimes called the
maximum vapor pressure surface, can be defined in three-dimensional space defined by
temperature, humidity and pressure or two dimensional surface defined by temperature and
humidity. Fog occurs when the saturation surface is reached. In order to conserve energy, micro
controller 26 performs the following operations. First the atmospheric pressure is measured in
step 80. In step 82 the humidity is measured. In step 84 the temperature is measured. Each of
the atmospheric pressure, humidity and temperature conditions are preferably measured outside
the housing of the highway visibility detector system. From the condition measured in steps 80
through 84, step 86 determines the distance from the saturation surface. In step 88, the distance
from the saturation surface is compared with the previous distance from the saturation surface
to determine the speed that the saturation surface is being approached. In step 90, the time to
14
reach the saturation surface is estimated. In step 92, the sample rate is changed so that the micro
controller will turn on to determine visibility at a higher rate if the saturation surface is being
approached. One method for setting the sample rate may be that if the estimated time to reach
saturation is below 3 hours, then the micro controller will turn on at a rate twice as fast as the
normal operation mode. For example, this faster rate may be twice an hour. As the estimated
time goes lower, the sample rate can be further increased. By increasing the time of sample only
when the saturation surface is being approached, energy is conserved. After executing step 92,
step 80 is re-executed and the next sample period determined by the micro controller.
In this manner, the highway visibility detector system 10 does not operate
needlessly. Thus, energy is conserved.
In operation, during visibility sampling, the first light source illuminates a sample
volume 30 beneath housing 24. Fog or dust particles cause light to be scattered from the sample
volume 30 into first detector 56. The amount of light scattered will be dependent upon the
particle size and/or the number of particles of the contaminants within the sample volume 30.
The light scattered from the sample volume has a direct correlation to the visibility present
around the highway visibility detector. Date acquisition may be taken once or preferably
sampled a number of times to statistically ensure satisfactory results. The received voltage level
corresponding to the amount of illumination on the first detector 56 may be converted by a micro
controller 26 into a visibility. Micro controller 26 may also convert the visibility into a safe
speed for the roadway. The safe speed may be calculated or looked up in a table stored in
memory 32.
The sensor system also has the ability to self calibrate. During manufacturing,
a light scattering calibration object may be positioned in the sample volume. The micro
15
controller, when commanded, can save the measurement and determine a correction factor to be
stored in the non-volatile memory. The connection factor will be used to correct subsequent
visibility measurements. Calibration may easily be done at the manufacturer and easily
confirmed when installed in the field.
Referring now to Figures 5 and 6, in certain implementations of the invention it
may be desirable to have a sensor head 100 that is easily removable and replaceable. In such a
manner, servicing time of the visibility sensor would be reduced. A sensor enclosure 102 defines
first optical port 42 and second optical port 44. A center wall 104 separates first optical port 42
from second optical port 44. End pieces 106 and 108 of each port 42 and 44 opposite center wall
104 have end pieces 106 and 108 respectively. Each end piece 106 and 108 are respectively used
to secure circuit boards 110 and 112 thereto. Sensor enclosure 102 of removable sensor head 100
has a bottom surface 120 that has first hollow opening 54 and second hollow opening 58 similar
to that described above.
Circuit board 110 is also used to secure light source 52. Circuit board 110 may
also be used to secure a connector 113 which is used to supply power to light source 52.
Connector 113 may be one of a variety of types of connectors including being a male or female
end of a snap in or screw type connector. Connector 113 should allow easy connection and
disconnection to facilitate removal of removable sensor head 100. A plurality of wires 117 may
be used to couple light source 52 to a power source or microcontroller.
Circuit board 112 is secured to photo detector 56. Photo detector 56 is preferably
coupled to infrared filter 60 as described above. Circuit board 112 preferably has an amplifier
62 mounted thereto. By mounting amplifier 62 to circuit board 112, noise transmission through
connecting wire 118 is reduced. Circuit board 112 also preferably has a calibration memory 116
16
coupled thereto. Functionally, calibration memory 116 may be part of memory 32 shown in
Figure 2. By locating calibration memory 116 on circuit board 112, the calibrations associated
with the removable sensor head 100 are also removed. When a replacement sensor head 100 is
coupled to the visibility sensor system, micro controller 26 uses the information stored in
calibration memory 116 to generate the required results.
Commercially, photo detectors are often packaged together with an amplifier 62.
A wire or a plurality of wires 118 are used to couple connector 114 to the remaining circuitry of
the visibility sensor.
Referring now to Figure 6, first hollow opening 54 and second hollow opening
58 within bottom surface 120 are preferably oval in shape. The oval shape has been found to be
beneficial in providing a high signal to noise ratio for the fog detection system, as well as
providing the least signal deterioration due to contamination of the surface of first light source
52.
A shutter 122 shown on second hollow opening 58 may be used to cover second
hollow opening 58 to prevent contamination of photo detector 56. Of course, a second shutter
may also be incorporated in a similar manner over first hollow opening 54 to prevent
contamination of light source 52. Shutter 122 is preferably a simple solenoid operated device.
Shutter 122 may be switch operated, operated manually or automatically operated. One manner
for automatically operating shutter 122 is to estimate the likelihood of fog with respect to the
approachment of a saturation surface as described above. As the saturation surface is
approached, shutter 122 may be opened. To prevent shutter 122 from opening in a car wash, the
system may be coupled to a sensor in the transmission of the vehicle that senses whether the
17
vehicle is in neutral, park or the engine is stopped. Commonly vehicles are placed in neutral when being washed in a car wash. This prevents soap film from fouling the sensors.
To reiterate, one of the problems of conventional fog sensors for automotive
applications involves keeping the sensor "window" surface clean. Most of the conventional
sensor system attempts for an automotive application fail because of this problem. As described
above, and in accordance with the present invention, an inventive sensor enclosure configuration
eliminates a sensor "window", and further, optionally employs means, such as one or more
shutters, for covering the "windowless" openings during no-fog conditions. Such shutters are
only opened when, as described above, a fog prediction algorithm indicates that fog is likely.
Also as described above, the shutters may be closed during, for example, car washing, or when
the car is parked. This mode of operation minimizes contamination when the visibility sensor
functionality is not needed. The foregoing approach may be implemented by including means
for generating a closure signal, which is applied to the shutters, when a closure condition exists.
The closure condition may be one condition selected from the group consisting of a condition
where a transmission of an automotive vehicle is in a neutral condition, a condition where the
transmission is in a parked condition, and a condition where an engine of the vehicle is stopped.
In addition, it should be understood that the presence of fog is unlikely during rain
or snow. Accordingly, in one embodiment, precipitation sensor 35, such as a rain sensor or a
snow sensor, is provided which generates an output signal. The output signal, in one
embodiment, may be directed to microcomputer 26, which in turn is configured to generate the
closure signal. The closure signal is then applied to one or both of the shutters 122 (Figure 2 and
Figure 6) to cause them to close and cover the first and second openings. In an alternative
embodiment, an output of sensor 35 may be used directly (i.e., not directed through
18
microcomputer 26) to close shutters 122 to thereby cover openings 54 and 58. As is well known,
rain sensor 35 may comprise a piezo-electric plate which produces a voltage when a pressure is
applied.
An alternative embodiment of the inventive system of detecting rain or snow
involves analyzing the light scattering characteristic of rain and/or snow (relative to the light
scattering characteristic of fog). To fully appreciate this aspect of the invention, a description
of a synchronous detection technique used in accordance with the present invention will be
briefly described.
Referring to Figure 15, the top trace thereof represents the ON and OFF control
signals generated by microcontroller 26 indicative of the ON and OFF states of light source 52.
Further, photodetector 56 is configured to generate a signal having a magnitude corresponding
to the intensity of the received light. Therefore, when light source 52 is OFF, photodetector 56
generates an output signal having a magnitude corresponding to the intensity of only the ambient
light. When light source 52 is ON, however, photodetector 56 generates an output signal having
a magnitude corresponding to the intensity of a combination of the ambient light, and the light
scattered from sample volume 30 from light source 52.
Referring now to the middle trace in Figure 15, microcontroller 26 internally
generates a sealer or multiplier parameter which alternates in polarity, in synchronous registry
with the ON/OFF states of light source 52. That is, when light source 52 is ON, the multiplier
is "+1", while when the light source 52 is OFF, the multiplier is "-1".
In operation, the sealer is used to filter out the effect of ambient light (bias
component). Referring now to the bottom trace of Figure 15, during a first time slot when light
source 52 is ON, the multiplier is "+1". The output of photodetector 56 is multiplied or scaled
19
by the multiplier parameter (middle trace). Therefore, the output of detector 56 is maintained in
a positive polarity state, and is represented diagrammatically as the combination of AL,, and SL,.
During the next time slot, when light source 52 is OFF, the multiplier is "-1". During this time
slot, the output of detector 56 corresponds solely to the ambient light. The resulting product is
of a negative polarity, and is designated AL2 in Figure 15. Over the course of a preselected
interval ("time constant"), designated in the lower trace of Figure 15 as "TC", the area under the
curve is added by microcontroller 26 having due regard for the indicated polarity. The ambient
light terms (i.e., AL,, AL2, AL3, AL4, . . . , ALg ) cancel out or, in other words, net out to "zero".
Since the sealer is always "+1" when light source 52 is ON, the accumulated value resulting from
the "addition" operation is a function only of the scattered light derived from sample volume 30
due to the illumination thereof by light source 52 (i.e., the sum of SL,, SL2, . . . , SL4). The
magnitude of the accumulated scattered light is then correlated to predetermined data, and a
measure of visibility is determined thereby. For example, the time constant TC, when used to
detect fog, may be selected to be between about 10-60 seconds, and may be up to several
minutes.
However, in accordance with the present invention, raindrops (or snowflakes) can
be analyzed (i.e., detected) by shortening the time constant TC, which may be selected to be
between about 10-20 milliseconds, up to about 100 milliseconds. Individual readings (i.e., one
reading is the accumulated value over one time constant TC) compared with each, for example,
over a relatively long period of time relative to the selected time constant (i.e., a detection
interval), such as one minute, if widely fluctuating, are indicative of raindrops or snowflakes.
In contrast, if each of the individual readings show little variation in magnitude (i.e., smooth),
then what is being detected is likely fog.
20
Preferably, whether a dedicated sensor 35 is used, or whether precipitation (rain
or snow) is determined parametrically by shortening the time constant as described above,
preferably at least two, and most preferably at least three of such sensors 35 (or sensor head
assembly 28 when precipitation is detected parametrically) are used to minimize false detections.
Use of a plurality of sensors is also preferred for fog detection as well. False signals, caused by
many reasons other than fog or rain (or snow), can be significantly reduced using two sensors
simultaneously. For example, sensor head 28 may be employed in both a right and a left fog
lamp assembly, as shown diagrammatically in Figure 16.
Referring now to Figures 7 and 8, a housing 124 is shown having a removable
sensor head 100 and an electronic module 126. Electronic module 126 may have different
variations. Preferably, electronic module 126 contains many of the features of Figure 2 such as
a micro controller 26, a memory 32 and a communications link 40. Also in some applications
electronic module contains algorithms to determine the true fog occurrence from such data
provided by an atmospheric pressure sensor 34, a temperature sensor 36, a humidity sensor 38.
The sensors may be coupled to each fog sensor. To reduce cost and avoid redundancy, however,
one or all sensors may be located in a central location if a group of visibility sensors are used in
a single system, for example, along a highway.
Bottom surface 120 of removable sensor head 100 is preferably flush with bottom
surface 128 of housing 124. For applications, where the visibility sensor will be mounted to a
moving vehicle, providing bottom surface 120 of sensor head 100 flush with bottom surface 128
of housing 124 does not disturb the laminar flow near openings 54 and 58.
Removable sensor head 100 may be snap fit within housing 124. A mechanical
fastening device 130 may also be used to secure removable sensor head 100 within housing 124.
21
Mechanical fastening device 130 may, for example, be used in conjunction with screws or other
fasteners to secure sensor head 100 within housing 124. The particular mechanical fastening
device 130 is preferably relatively easy to disassembly and reassembly to facilitate replacement
of sensor head 100.
Electronic module 126 may also be designed to be easily removed from within
housing 124. In the practical sense, sensor head 100 is more likely to be replaced or serviced.
Electronic module 126 may be coupled to an external power supply through a connector 132.
Connector 132 may also be used to couple electronic module 126 to a remote display 134.
Display 134 may also be coupled through a central computer or host controller. Remote display
134 may be a warning signal or an audible signal. Remote display 134 may provide an indication
as to the distance of visibility. Display may be a visual indicator, an audible indicator or a
combination of the two. If the fog sensor is coupled to a vehicle, the visual indicator may be
incorporated into an instrument panel or a heads-up display. The audible indicator may be a
buzzer or be coupled to he audio system of the vehicle.
A gasket 136 may be used between removable sensor head 100 and housing 124
to prevent infiltration of moisture into housing 124. Likewise, connector 132 may be a sealed
connector to prevent water from entering housing 124.
Referring now to Figure 8, a heater 138 may be coupled adjacent to first hollow
opening 58 and second hollow opening 54. By placing heater 138 near openings 54 and 58, frost
is prevented from building up around either opening. If frost forms on the edge of either
opening, the accuracy of the detector system may be affected.
22
In operation, removable sensor head 100 has thus been made easy to remove and
replace from housing 124. To replace removable sensor head 100, mechanical fastening device
130 releases removable sensor head 100. Connectors 113 and 114 are disconnected.
To connect a replacement sensor head, connectors 113 and 114 are connected to
removable sensor head 100. Mechanical fastening device 130 is coupled to the replacement
sensor head 100. The calibration data from calibration memory 116 is then communicated to
micro controller 26. The calibration data was stored within calibration memory 116 during
manufacture of the sensor head.
Referring now to Figures 9 and 10, the removable sensor head configuration is
particularly suitable for implementation within an automotive vehicle. This feature may be
included as an after-market application or as original equipment. One manner for implementing
a removable sensor head 100 into an automobile is to place removable sensor head 100 into a rear
view mirror housing 140. Removable sensor head 100 is preferably placed behind mirror 142
and directed in a downward position. Bottom surface 120 of sensor head 110 is preferably flush
with bottom 144 of rear view mirror housing 140. In this manner, the laminar flow of air around
mirror housing 140 is least disturbed.
Electronic module 126 may also be incorporated within rear view mirror housing
140. However, electronic module 126 may easily be incorporated into the interior of the
automotive vehicle. By placing electronic module 126 within the interior of the automotive
vehicle, the electronics are not subjected to the harsh weather conditions and thus may increase
the accuracy and life of electronic module 126.
It is desirable to include shutters 122 in an automotive application. It is desirable
to close shutters 122 during a car wash to prevent soap residue from building on the light detector
23
or light source. By providing shutters 122, the life of sensor head 100 may be increased.
Shutters 122 may also be applied to a highway sign application.
Referring now to Figure 11, an automotive vehicle 146 has a roof 148. A
removable sensor head 100 is shown coupled near the rear end of roof 148. Sensor head 100 may
be positioned to reduce wind resistance. Electronic module 126 may be placed in many areas of
vehicle including within the interior of the vehicle adjacent to display unit 134 with appropriate
wiring. Display unit 134 and electronic module 126 may, for example, be mounted to a rear view
mirror within the vehicle.
Electronic module 126 may also be coupled to vehicle battery 150 which provides
power for the entire detector system 10.
Sensor head 10 may be removable or fixed when included in an automotive
vehicle. Sensor head 10 may, for example, be placed in the trim around the rear window of the
vehicle. In such a manner, sensor head 100 becomes unobtrusive.
Referring now to Figures 12, 13 and 14, removable sensor head 100 may be
detachable from automotive vehicle 146. By providing a detachable housing 152, visibility
detector system 10 is particularly suited for after-market automotive applications. Detachable
housing 152 preferably has magnets 150 suitable for coupling detachable housing 152 to a steel
component such as roof 148 or a vehicle door 155.
Removable sensor head 100 may be removed from and coupled to detachable
housing 152 as described above. As is best shown in Figures 13 and 14, the housing 152 may
have legs 156. Legs 156 have magnets 150 therein for attachment to the automotive vehicle.
As shown in Figure 13, sample volume 30 may be between detachable housing
152 and the exterior automotive vehicle 146.
24
As shown in Figure 14, sample volume 30 may be directed away from automotive
vehicle 146.
For an after-market application, an automotive vehicle owner merely couples the
detachable housing 152 to the outside of automotive vehicle 146. Display device 132 and
electronic module 134 may, for example, be clipped to a rear view mirror within the passenger
compartment of automotive vehicle 146. Electronic module 126 may, for example, be powered
through the cigar lighter of the automotive vehicle which is coupled to vehicle battery 150. One
cable having a plurality of wires may be used to couple detachable housing 152 and removable
sensor head 100 therein to electronic module 126.
In operation, a sensor head for an automotive vehicle may be used to activate the
fog lights that are commonly found on the front of vehicles (and the rear of vehicles in Europe).
Such a system may work as follows: once the saturation detects that fog is likely, the shutters
122 are opened; if fog is detected, the fog lights of the vehicle may then be illuminated.
Figure 16 shows exemplary vehicle 20 including a first and a second combination
visibility sensor/fog lamp apparatus 200. Apparatus 200, in one embodiment, is an integral unit
including the functionality of the above-described visibility sensor with the illumination
functionality of a conventional fog lamp assembly. As shown in Figure 16, apparatus 200 may
be disposed in a front bumper fascia of vehicle 20.
An automotive fog sensor according to this invention is characterized by a no
window/no lens approach, an optimal airflow design, may include an optional shutter, and may
be deployed as a 2 or 3 unit system for double or triple redundancy, respectively.
The no window/no lens approach eliminates window surface contamination.
Optimal airflow design minimizes air turbulence, produces an air-curtain to minimize IR
25
LED/photo-detector contamination, and may use "filtered" air for the IR LED/photo-detector
chamber. The optional shutter may be (i) activated by a "fog prediction filter" using
humidity/temperature sensors; (ii) activated by a gear position (closed at neutral/park); or
(iii) activated by a rain or precipitation detector (closed in the rain). Double/triple redundancy
in the system (e.g., sensor installed in both fog lamps like as shown in Figure 16) enhances
reliability.
The embodiments illustrated in Figures 17-18, and Figures 19-20 will be referred
to hereinafter as "look-forward" embodiments, inasmuch as the optically sensitive volume 30 is
"forward" of the apparatus, relative to the direction of travel of the vehicle. Figures 17 and 18
show a first embodiment of apparatus 200, which includes a unit housing assembly 210, a lamp
assembly 212, and a visibility sensor head assembly 214. As illustrated in Figure 18, apparatus
200 may include one or more electrical connections to electronic module 126, to thereby access
the functionality of the electronic module 126, which is illustrated and described in connection
with, for example, in Figure 2. As described above, and in the Background, a problem with
conventional visibility sensors involves contamination of the light source/photo-detector and/or
surfaces or structures ("windows") through which the illumination light and the signal light must
pass. To address this problem, and in accordance with the present invention, apparatus 200
includes an improved sensor enclosure configured for contamination reduction.
With continued reference to Figures 17 and 18, unit housing assembly 210
includes a plurality of relatively thin-walled structures 216,, 2162, 2163, and 2164. The thin-
walled structures may comprise conventional and well-known materials.
Lamp assembly 212 is configured to produce illumination in response to an
excitation signal, and may generally comprise conventional and well-known components and
26
materials. Lamp assembly 212 may include a reflector 218, a bulb 220, a lens or other light
transmissive material 222, and an electrical connection 224 for connecting bulb 220 to a source
of electrical power such as may be controlled by microcontroller 26 (i.e., the excitation signal)
and wherein the electrical power may be supplied by power source 76.
Sensor head assembly 214 includes a sensor enclosure 226 having a plurality of
relatively thin-walled structures ("walls") 228,, 2282, 2283, and 2284. Walls 228, (where i = 1 to
4) define a first optical port 230 having a first opening 232, and walls 228, further define a second
optical port 234 having a second opening 236. Optical port 230 is a volume bounded in-part by
wall 2282 on the top, and wall 2284 on the right (with reference to Figure 17), while optical port
234 is bounded in-part on the left by wall 2284, and wall 2282 on the top. First optical port 230
is optically isolated from second optical port 234 primarily by intervening wall 2284. Sensor
enclosure 226 further includes an exit opening 238, a first deflector 240 having a first aperture
242 and a second aperture 244, and a second deflector 246.
Light source 52, and photodetector 56 are located in respective relatively
"concealed" positions within first optical port 230, and second optical port 234. "Concealed" in
this context means positions that are difficult for contaminants (such as moisture, water, dust,
etc.) to reach. In the illustrated embodiment, sensor enclosure 226 and light source 52 (disposed
in first optical port 230) are configured to emit a light beam through first aperture 242 and first
opening 232 to illuminate sample volume 30 located outside apparatus 200. Likewise, in the
illustrated embodiment, enclosure 226 and light detector 56 (disposed in second optical port 234)
are configured to detect light through second aperture 244 and second opening 236. Detector 56
generates an output signal in response thereto indicative of the amount of light scattered from
particles contained in the sample volume 30 (after the signal is "filtered"— as described above to
27
remove contributions of ambient light). As illustrated, openings 232 and 236 are located on a
first side of deflector 240, while light source 52 and photodetector 56 are located on a second
side opposite the first side of deflector 240. Inasmuch as openings 232 and 236 are in direct
communication with the ambient environment—the source of contaminants—the foregoing
arrangement (/. e. , use of deflectors and use of "concealed" positions) provides a barrier reducing
or minimizing the entry of dust, water or other contaminants. In addition, as the vehicle 20
moves in a forward direction, respective air flows occur along the paths indicated by arrows
designated 248 in the drawings. Dust, water, or other contaminants in the air will pass through
the sensor enclosure 226 along the air flow path. This flow-through action reduces the likelihood
that the surfaces of light source 52 and photodetector 56 will become contaminated.
In addition, by selecting a proper air flow path difference between the inside of
enclosure 226 relative to the outside of enclosure 226, and, further, by selecting proper sizes for
the openings 232, 236 and 238, an air pressure differential can be established. That is, one can
make the air pressure adjacent and around light source 52 and photodetector 56 higher than the
pressure in the central portion of enclosure 226. This pressure differential feature helps reduce
contamination. Basic principles of aerodynamics may be used to make the above selections.
Thus, two features of the above-described configuration combine to keep the
surfaces of light source 52 and photodetector 56 clean: (1) a "concealed" position feature
wherein the source 52 and photodetector 56 are located in "concealed" positions (e.g., above the
apertures, and openings, through which the illumination and receiving light beams pass); and (2)
a pressure differential feature wherein the enclosure and deflectors and openings are configured
to create suitable air paths to establish a pressure differential to thereby assist in keeping the
28
surfaces of source 52 and detector 56 clean. With the foregoing implementation, the use of one
or more shutters, such as shutters 122 in Figure 6, is optional.
Figures 19 and 20 illustrate a second preferred embodiment of the apparatus
shown in Figure 17 and 18, namely apparatus 200'. Apparatus 200' is substantially similar to
apparatus 200, except that apparatus 200' does not include second deflector 246, but in lieu
thereof includes exit opening 238 that is positioned at a distal end of an air flow channel 250.
Apparatus 200' illustrates just one of the plurality of variations and modifications of enclosure
226 possible which are adapted to create air flow path differences to thereby establish the above-
described pressure differential arrangement.
Figures 21 and 22 illustrate yet another preferred embodiment, namely apparatus
200". Apparatus 200" will be referred to as a "look-down" embodiment wherein the optically
sensitive volume 30 is located on the "down" side or downward of the apparatus enclosure,
relative to the direction of travel of vehicle 20. Apparatus 200" includes unit housing 210, lamp
assembly 212, and sensor head assembly 214". Unit housing 210 and lamp assembly 212 may
comprise structure and function as described above in connection with the embodiments
illustrated in Figures 17-20. Sensor head assembly 214" includes a sensor enclosure 226"
having a plurality of walls 228,, 2282, 2283, 2284, and 2285, that define a first optical port having
a first opening and a second optical port having a second opening, as described above in
connection with apparatus 200. Enclosure 226" includes a deflector 240" having first and
second apertures 242, and 244. In the illustrated embodiment, apparatus 200' ' creates an air flow
path difference that establishes a pressure differential in the same manner and to the same effect
as described above in connection with apparatus 200 and 200'. Figure 21 is a bottom view of
29
Figure 22. In addition, apparatus 200" includes an air filter 260 configured to filter air for the
IR LED 52/photodetector 56 chamber. This is shown in both Figures 21 and 22.
Figures 23 and 24 illustrate still yet another preferred embodiment of the present
invention, namely apparatus 200'". Apparatus 200'" includes a unit housing 210, a lamp
assembly 212, and a sensor head assembly 214'". Unit housing 210, and lamp assembly 212
may comprise structure and function as described above in connection with the embodiments
illustrated in Figures 17-22. Apparatus 200'" may be generally cylindrical in shape, and
comprise a sensor enclosure 226'" that includes a first deflector 240'", and a second deflector
246'". Walls, including thin walls 256,, and 2562, in-part, define first optical port 230, and
second optical port 236. First and second openings 232 and 236 are best shown in Figure 23.
First deflector 240'" includes first aperture 242'", and second aperture 244'", while second
deflector 246'" is illustrated as including third aperture 252, and fourth aperture 254. Apertures
242'", and 252 are, generally, in registry, while apertures 244'" and 254 are, likewise, generally
in registry. The foregoing configuration permits light source 52 to generate a light beam to
illuminate optically sensitive sample volume 30, while the apertures as described above permit
photodetector 56 to receive light therethrough from scattered particles in the optically sensitive
sample volume 30. Operation of apparatus is generally the same, in manner and effect, as
described above in connection with apparatus 200.
Certain other improvements are shown in Figures 21-22 and 25-28.
In addition to passing air through the sensor enclosure in front of the apertures for
IR LED and photodetector (e.g., 242, 244 in Figure 19/20), a small hole is made to the IR
LED/photodetector chambers and is covered with an air-filter 260. With this configuration, high
pressure air 266 goes through the filter 260 wherein clean air continuously flows in the chambers
30
to prevent contamination on the surfaces of the LED 52 and detector 56 (as if one were
continuously using a vacuum cleaner to clean the surfaces). This is shown in both Figures 21-22
(apparatus 200") and Figures 25-26 (apparatus 200iv).
Figures 25-26, in addition, show a support 262, and a shutter 264 installed at
opening 236. In addition, there may be provided a second shutter 264 at opening 232. These
shutters 264 may be controlled in a manner described hereinbefore to selectively cover the
openings and isolate the inside chamber from external environmental factors.
Air-flow channels are shown in Figure 27. This channel, which is formed by the
under surface of apparatus 200 and the upper surface 270 of bumper portion 268, creates a
"steady" air current which works as an "air-curtain" for the openings, keeping external
contaminants out.
Figure 28 shows a modularized sensor head unit 100', being configured to be
removable relative to enclosure 102', in a manner similar to that described above for removable
sensor head 100 and enclosure 102.
While the best mode for carrying out the present invention has been described in
detail, those familiar with the art to which this invention relates will recognize various alternative
designs and embodiments for practicing the invention as defined by the following claim. For
example, the humidity, temperature and atmospheric pressure sensors may be replaced by a wind
velocity sensors if this invention were to be used to measure visibility in blowing dust.
31